According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly half of all American adults live with at least one chronic illness, such as MS, HIV/AIDS, COPD, lupus, Crohn’s disease, and fibromyalgia—to name just a few.
Here are the types of statements you might want to think twice about:
1. “Disease is all in the mind.”
Margit Crane of Seattle, Wash., was diagnosed with fibromyalgia in 1985. She reports that well-meaning people sometimes try to “help” by telling her that she can think her way out of feeling ill.
So beware of suggesting that positive thinking is the cure someone needs. While a positive attitude may help in some situations, you never want to make someone feel bad about feeling bad.
2. “You don’t look sick to me.”
Pamela Gilchrist, who lives in the greater Cincinnati area and also has fibromyalgia, says that an airline gate agent once even asked her, accusingly, “Why do you need a wheelchair? Do you have cancer?”
According to the CDC, a quarter of people living with chronic conditions say that they experience significant limitations in daily activities, but many of those people don’t have visible symptoms.
3. “Have you lost weight? You look great!”
In our diet-obsessed culture, it’s easy to assume that all weight loss is welcome. Not so for many people like Cedar Burnett, who has ulcerative colitis. Burnett says, “When I’m really sick with this disease, I can drop 10 pounds in a matter of days … typically, the thinner I am, the sicker I am, so it’s pretty disturbing to hear people congratulate me for weight loss.”
Remember that commenting on someone’s physical appearance—especially if you don’t know him or her very well—is one of the most common ways to put your foot in your mouth!
4. “I’m sorry.”
Josh Robbins, an HIV activist, blogger, and author, says that he often hears this response when he tells people that he is living with HIV—it’s a pet peeve, and he even created a video about “what not to say to someone who just disclosed their HIV status.” He says, “Instead, I suggest saying, ‘I’m here for you.’”
Keep in mind that a chronic condition is definitely not a funeral. Condolences will likely seem out of place.
5. “I’m sure things will get better.”
Mark Black of New Brunswick, Canada, had a heart-lung transplant to deal with chronic congestive heart failure. He points out that empty platitudes about “getting better” can make a person feel misunderstood: Sometimes, he points out, “this is clearly not true.”
Sure, platitudes may have their place, but often a sympathetic ear will help someone with a chronic condition a lot more.
6. “Did you get this because you ___?”
Cynthia McKay is a psychotherapist who works with families dealing with chronic illness—she says that insensitive people often ask whether a person’s smoking, weight, or what-have-you led to a condition. And blame is the last thing that a person whose health has been impacted by an illness or accident needs.
Any comments that lean into “I told you so” territory are going to cause trouble. Before you ask questions like this, ask yourself, “Do I need to know this in order to help or provide support?”
7. “My aunt’s cousin’s best friend who shares your disease is doing great!”
Dave Bexfield runs ActiveMSers.org, a nonprofit website designed to inspire people with multiple sclerosis to stay as active as possible. He notes that diseases like MS are very variable and can affect people in very different ways.
So in addition to asking yourself, “Do I need to know this?” before asking a question, you could also ask yourself, “Is what I’m about to say helpful?” before speaking.
8. “I know exactly how it feels to have a severe skin condition; I have my eyebrows waxed monthly.”
Writer, speaker, and activist Carly Findlay is living with ichthyosis, a skin condition that affects her appearance and that can be painful. On her blog, she has posted a long list of shouldn’t-have-said-that comments strangers have made—including the doozy above.
Unless you really, really, really know exactly how someone feels, don’t say you do. Instead, ask, “How are you?”—and open yourself up to hearing the answer.
9. “You’re so brave.”
Marisa Zeppieri-Caruana is a board member for the Lupus Foundation of America. She, too, has a blog where she has detailed her least-favorite comments. She says she doesn’t feel “brave” (not having volunteered for lupus) but rather feels “strong.”
There’s a big difference between pity and empathy. And sometimes, you don’t have to say anything. Just being there is enough.
10. “You’re so strong—I wouldn’t be able to walk around looking like that.”
Dr. Toral Patel is a dermatologist who often works with patients who are managing chronic skin conditions. She says that we should all beware of “compliments” that also deliver an insult, as this one does.
Sure, compliments are great—but know when to end them.
11. “You should try this amazing herbal remedy.”
Ted Meyer of Los Angeles has Gaucher’s disease, an enzyme deficiency. His biggest beef is people who indicate that his rare genetic disorder has a simple cure—herbs or vitamins, for instance—that he’s somehow unaware of.
Lesson: Leave medical advice to the professionals. Depending on a person’s condition, inexpert advice could actually be dangerous.
12. “It could be worse.”
Psychotherapist Toni Coleman works with many people who have been diagnosed with a chronic or life-altering condition. She says that condescending remarks like these—and her personal favorite, “God never gives us more than we can handle”—only add to a person’s feelings of aloneness.
Avoid measuring a person’s suffering, pain, or discomfort. (And knowing that things could get worse is hardly cheerful news.)
So What Should We Say?
When we’re not feeling well or are frightened about our health, advice is often the last thing we want. What’s more important is simply being listened to—and knowing that we’re being heard.
Larry Berkelhammer, Ph.D., the author of In Your Own Hands: New Hope for People with Chronic Medical Conditions, recommends paraphrasing the key points of what the person with a chronic condition has shared with you.
“Paraphrasing is a particularly effective way of reflecting back what you heard, because then the other person knows that you not only were listening, but that you understood,” Berkelhammer said.
So a sentence like, “I hear you saying that things seem pretty hopeless right now,” or, “It sounds like the pain is really bad today—how can I help?” opens the door more to an expanded, supportive conversation, unlike unsolicited advice.
Keep in mind that every person is different, and every relationship is different. When in doubt, tread lightly, or even ask how to proceed: “I am here for you, but I’m not sure how to discuss things. Tell me about your condition and what you prefer.”